Greg 的个人资料A Legend In My Own Mind日志列表 工具 帮助
7月21日

Why I Think Natalie Holloway Was Raped

Natalie Holloway, of course, is the 18 year old young woman from Alabama who disappeared in Aruba at the end of May and whose case has been all over the news, expecially Fox News, since then.  Since her body has not been found and none of the suspects has given an account of what happened there has been alot of speculation.  And some of that speculation is pretty bad.  Two theories that I think can pretty much be ruled out are that she died from a drug or alcohol overdose or as an accident during sexual intercourse.  The first was put forward by a former homicide detective last night on O'Reilly and the latter by another supposed expert on Fox News recently. 
 
Here's what we know about the case: Natalie had been seen hanging out with Joran on days prior to her disappearance; there was likely a romantic connection between the two; on the night of her disappearance, she left the bar with Joran and his friends, the Kalpoe brothers; they claim to have dropped her off at her hotel but the video surveillance has no record of that; Joran and the Kalpoe brothers have lied, changed their stories a number of times and are being generally uncooperative; Paul van der Sloot, Joran's father, is also being somewhat uncooperative with police.
 
Let me say this first: if someone is missing and you have nothing to do with it, even if you were last seen with the person, you tell the truth.  I think that is the natural human response.  If you know you didn't do anything wrong, you cooperate with the authorities by telling them what you know.  One reason is that you are innocent and believe that that will come to light when you tell the truth since everything that is discovered in the future will be consistent with your innocence, since you are in fact innocent.  Second, if you know this person who is missing, you would likely want to do everything you could to help her be found or at least for it to be discovered what happened to her, since you would likely be genuinely concerned about her and her family.
 
So the very fact that Joran and the Kalpoe brothers have lied and are being uncooperative is very strong evidence that they did something wrong. 
 
If she simply died of a drug or alcohol overdose, there was no reason for them to get rid of the body.  I think that's obvious.  It's not a crime if someone you know overdoses.  So much for that first theory.  As for the second theory, if a woman dies while you are having consensual sex with her, either because she is very intoxicated or you are too rough with her or a combination, that is, of course, a huge tragedy and difficult to deal with, but it is not criminal.  In either of these cases, since no crime was committed, there was no reason for Joran not to call the police immediately. 
 
One hypothesis that I've also heard is that Joran left her on the beach after doing whatever they did and whatever happened to her happened after he left.  Again, this doesn't fit with the fact that he is lying, changing his story and being uncooperative.  If this is what happened, you tell the truth and go get the "real killers" - who, on this hypothesis, happen to actually exist. 
 
What seems very likely is Joran raped Natalie and the Kalpoe brothers either helped or participated.  They either killed her in the process or killed her afterwards when they realized that she would report them and they would be in big trouble.  Then they got rid of the body to try and cover this up.  This fits with the previous romantic relationship between Joran and Natalie.  It fits with three young men leaving a bar late at night with an attractive and intoxicated young woman.  And it fits with the fact that Joran and the Kalpoe brothers are lying and being uncooperative. 
 
The problem of course is that this is all circumstantial evidence.  Everybody always wants direct evidence such as physical evidence, like Natalie's blood on Joran's clothes or under his fingernails, or eyewitness testimony.  Even without this, though, I think it's highly likely that Natalie Holloway was at least raped and accidentally killed in the process or, more likely, raped and killed afterwards.  In the absence of physical evidence, Joran should be tried for rape and accidental death (manslaughter) and the Kalpoe brothers for aiding him.  Since we can't know if the murder was accidental or intentional or if the Kalpoe brothers merely helped Joran or participated, they should be tried for the lesser charge which the circumstantial evidence seems to strongly support.  That's my opinion at least.

评论 (18)

请稍候...
很抱歉,您输入的评论太长。请缩短您的评论。
您没有输入任何内容,请重试。
很抱歉,我们当前无法添加您的评论。请稍后重试。
若要添加评论,需要您的家长授予您相应权限。请求权限
您的家长禁用了评论功能。
很抱歉,我们当前无法删除您的评论。请稍后重试。
您已超过了一天之内允许提供的评论数上限。请在 24 小时后重试。
因为我们的系统表明您可能在向其他用户提供垃圾评论,您的帐户已禁用了评论功能。如果您认为我们错误地禁用了您的帐户,请联系 Windows Live 支持部门
完成下面的安全检查,您提供评论的过程才能完成。
您在安全检查中键入的字符必须与图片或音频中的字符一致。

若要添加评论,请使用您的 Windows Live ID 登录(如果您使用过 Hotmail、Messenger 或 Xbox LIVE,您就拥有 Windows Live ID)。登录


还没有 Windows Live ID 吗?请注册

Lynn发表:
I would just like to add that I do not believe Joran left her on the beach alive. I believe that they were partying it up at "the popular local bar", she had a lot to drink, she was most likely slipped the date rape drug for reassurance of a much anticipated sexual ending in the mind of Joran, and or the Kalpoe brothers. (Meaning one of the three being Joran or the kalpoe brothers, or all three where probably in on slipping her a date rape drug.) I believe that most likely one of, if not all three of them had sex with her, her not being conscious or in a right state of mind. I believe that the alcohol plus the date rape drug was most likely just too much for her. I do not think that they intentionally killed her but was accidental. They probably panicked knowing that they had given her the date rape drug. Knowing that an autospy would reveal the drug in her system, they feared they would most likely be convicted of murder or at least manslaughter. So they panicked, got rid of the body and somehow made up that cockameme story about leaving her alive on the beach alone. With no body, there is no evidence, no autospy, no conviction. 
7 月 19 日
没有名字发表:
My heart goes out to the Holloway and Twitty families.  I have lost 3 children, so I know the pain of such loss.  I just don't understand why this has drug on  without having pinpointed the person(s) responsible for this horrendous crime.  I wonder what the Aruban people are going to do without the Mighty American Dollar now that many travelers have changed their minds about traveling to that picturesque but dangerous utopia.  See America First, is a good motto to follow. My next trip will be a long way from my native Texas - Alaska!!!
4 月 19 日
没有名字发表:
I don't know who tizzylizzy0 is, but I will finish this just to be able to move on.  Have a great day, everyone.
4 月 19 日
匿名 的图片
jamie 发表:
This whole Natalie Holloway situation just IRRITATES me.  Everyone is so eager to blame Joran.  Yes I think he did some wrongful things and was very dishonest, but no, I don't think that he killed the poor girl.  First of all, what was Natalie doing with three strangers she barely knew? I don't know what they teach in Alabama, but haven't you ever heard of the buddy system? I find it very strange that her friends just let her go off with three strangers all by herself.  And here in Georgia, when I go out, usually one of my friends would stay sober to watch out for guys preying on intoxicated girls to prevent things like this from happening.  So first, we need to question this......What had she told her friends? Secondly, I don't believe that Joran put a date rape drug in her drink because she would not be functional, at best disfunctional, if not passed out, but her friends saw her in the car with Joran and his friends.  I do, however; think that there is something fishy about Joran just leaving Natalie at the beach all alone, especially with her being intoxicated, but then again, guys do that to girls all of the time-they fool around with them and then leave........but it is just a strange situation.  My whole problem with this whole situation is this: I think the Arubian authorities did not do everything correctly or right and they did not do enough in the beginning because they thought this was just another tourist who just didn't come home so to speak, but by the time they realized something had really happened to Natalie, it was too late.  Did they every confiscate the car and search it?  Did they confiscate the clothing worn by Joran and test them? There are all kinds of things that could be found to finish telling this story.  For all we know some idiot could have picked Natalie up on side of the road and took her home and raped and killed her..............People are tearing Joran apart because that is all that they have.  i could understand if they found blood on his clothing or some evidence to tie him a crime, but just because he was the last person with Natalie doesn't mean he killed her.  If people would quit spending so much time harassing him, they might just find Natalie or her killer.............But that's just my opinion.
2 月 24 日
匿名 的图片
René 发表:
All i would like to say is that i'm truly sorry for what happened. I cannot believe the amount of pain the parents must have for losing their daughter (in such a way).
 
Me as a sober dutch guy just cannot believe what i just read on several Dutch news sites, Joran is being sued before the Civil Court. Which means the parents only want money instead of justice, that's what i think is wrong with the American Society...
 
Wouldn't you want to see the person who did this rot in prison instead of having a nice figure on your bank account??
 
Just a quick reation to PROUD2B AMERICAN, i would like to ask you not to say anything about our citizens and them being safe. I think people like you make America a twisted country and give it a bad name.
 
About the entire pot story: what do you think the first question is of any american kid/young man/woman....? Where is the nearest pot store? We have absolutely no problem with our soft-drug laws. It is the bigger criminals who have xtc labs and import/export cocaine who create the problems in the Netherlands. Same as any other country i recon.
 
Regards René
2 月 17 日
匿名 的图片
Ashlee 发表:
Well i guess everyone has their opinion but for the guy or girl who posted the first one u really need to think about what u  said yes u have every right to put ur opinion but u have no right to say those mean things about american people! The way i see it, is if u have n e kids and one of them got raped and u dont think taht u will ever get to see her or him alive again wouldnt u want to kill the person who was the main suspect?? i know i sure would!! but like i said u have ur opinion and i have mine! I have to agree on the sticking to the facts thing!
2 月 1 日
匿名 的图片
WillyWonka47 发表:
Let the folks at Jorans school in the Netherlands know how you feel, email them at:
international.abs@han.nl, or put pen to paper:
Han Voorlichtings Centrum (HVC)
PostBus 6960
6503 GL Nijmegen Netherlands
I for one will be sending my thoughts
9 月 28 日
匿名 的图片
Shannon 发表:
I would look strongly at the possibity Natallie was sold for money. I am sure we are all aware of the money it would take to support 9 atty's for poor little Liar Sloot's. However, if they worked with drug lords from a neighboring island or on Aruba, if they say anything, their family could be killed or harmed.

Might we request a phycic to go to Aruba and see what comes from it? I am not a phycic follower, but if we wait on the Liar Sloot's we will never have the answers for Natallie and her family.
8 月 13 日
匿名 的图片
Frances 发表:
I believe these 3 young boys are lying - however let's not forget the first mistake was Natalie's - why did she go with 3 strangers in the first place- intoxicated or not - how hard did anyone around really try to stop her - and the chaperones what has been their explanation to not being there- how sad it took $1,000,000 to get anyone to come foward - and of course the government is hiding - they waited how long before they really searched-- the landfill, the pond, cars, houses if they are even doing it now - they searched the ocean before a pond-no one should have been released--pressure the parents of all the teens not just 1 - my question to our government why couldn't they intervene -I hate to think my government has no power to rescue me - the Aruban people got mad when Natalie's mom got fustrated and vented - imagine someone is missing that is a part of you and you are getting no answers - I don't wish it on anyone but never say never - they certainly can't feel that safe anymore either -as far as the comments of those people about us being proud to be Americans aren't you proud to be whatever you are?
7 月 31 日
匿名 的图片
Tianawrit1 发表:
The real question is, would all this taboo be going on if Natalee Holloway was a minority? Something to think about.....
7 月 29 日
匿名 的图片
SheGlenda 发表:
Look, I don't know if she was raped or killed or simply just don't want to show her face to anyone. But what I do know is that the parents of Natalee need to talk with Silvia Brown. This woman really does know what she is talking about. Besides, if they did kill her, please let God handle them(those that commited the murder) and I promise you that God will make them pay for what they did. What was done in the dark will eventually come to the light.
To the Holloway family, stay strong and may God prove everyone to be wrong. May Natalee come home very very soon. God bless you all.
7 月 28 日
匿名 的图片
Tonia 发表:
I WOULD LOVE TO SEE A T-SHIRT COMPANY MAKE THOUSANDS OF T-SHIRTS WITH NATALIE HOLLOWAY'S BEAUTIFUL FACE ON THEM A GIVE THEM AWAY TO ANYONE IN ARUBA. HER FACE MUST BE A CONSTANT REMINDER TO EVERYONE THAT SHE IS IMPORTANT AND SHE SHOULD NOT BE FORGOTTEN.
7 月 26 日
匿名 的图片
Michael Jay Scarfo 发表:
What the hell? You need evidence before you start insisting on harsher punishments. "WHAT MORE EVIDENCE DO YOU NEED?!?!", I seem to recall you howling like a bewildered boar. You need plenty more evidence.

To charge someone with murder, you need proof of a death, and a body (while not -absolutely- necessary, couldn't hurt at all). To charge with rape, you need proof of a rape. A witness, semen found in the (nonexistent) body, et cet.

I understand you're upset. I think it's a sad story too. But not as sad as you "PROUD 2 B AMERICAN" types stomping all over civil liberties and freedoms.

P.S: Marijuana isn't the only legalized drug in the Netherlands; any recreational drug is legal for personal use. So your theory on marijuana being the gateway to drug violence and crime in Holland is false. Drug Lords don't compete for cocaine influence there.
7 月 24 日
匿名 的图片
PROUD 2B AMERICAN 发表:
By the way, my commentary is directed at "What does it matter.." not the original blogger...
7 月 23 日
匿名 的图片
PROUD 2B AMERICAN 发表:
Hmmm,
Well, I find it interesting that those who thank God they are not American keep reading our speculations on what happened in the Natalee Holloway case. Don't read it. Wherever you are from, I assume that it just doesn't matter in your country what happens to your citizens. If I was Dave Holloway, I might not be so forgiving as to hold hands with Paul VanderSloot and "respect" him for being a liar and a coward and enabling his spoiled snotty Dutch son to bring harm to another person with the help of his stupid friends. I guess that's okay in your country and you wouldn't even have a negative emotion about it. I assume from your commentary that you think anyone who wants retribution and justice for the MURDER of their daughter is somehow a violent person by nature. If ANYONE brings harm to my children, I will do whatever it takes to make them pay for it. If the law won't do it, I will. My children are PRECIOUS to me and I know that anyone who would lie about what they know about my childrens' disappearance is IMMORAL and deserves to be brought to justice. If the lame Dutch legal system couldn't do it, and the U.S. has no jurisdiction, then those directly involved with a crime of this type against my daughter had better watch out for me. I would not have to hire someone to make them tell me what happened - I would take care of it myself and they would tell the truth no matter what I had to do to make them tell the TRUTH.

Here are the "facts" in this case:
The facts remain that there is no evidence to be found in this disappearance. So, a list of known facts for you to think about, since I guess you don't have to think about crime where you are from - you must live in the Brave New World...

Fact 1:
Those three idiots stalked this girl.
Fact 2:
Those three idiots were seen taking her away from her travel group.
Fact 3:
Those three idiots did not demonstrate an appropriate level of concern for this girl when they learned she was missing..
Fact 4:
Those three idiots decided to make up a LIE about where they took her, what they did, who did what with her, and tried to blame "the black guys" for her disappearance. Gee - no sense of racist outrage from anyone on this, is there?
Fact 5:
The father - an even larger idiot - told his son (in front of Natalee's parents) to say nothing because there was no evidence. Perhaps this is because he is such a "great" legal mind and can't quit acting like a mock defense attorney, or perhaps it is because he knows the TRUTH and doesn't want his precious spoiled little brat to have to suffer the consequences of his own actions.
Fact 6:
The mother - a huge idiot - went on national television and said what all stupid women say about their spoiled little children "my baby wouldn't lie - he told me 'mommy, I wouldn't have been in the casino if you had been home,' " leading this idiot woman to further support the image of them as RIDICULOUS parents with an OUT-OF-CONTROL child who is involved in things he has no business being involved in.
Fact 7:
The Netherlands is not known for its ability to handle horrendous crimes. Remember, this is the little nation that could. They supposedly have a low crime rate, but it is increasing because of other legal activities (i.e., drugs). They have legal marijuana use (supposedly to cut down on the crimes in that nation), which has only given rise to other crimes with more serious drugs. This is not publicly discussed because they are proud of their pot shops, their pot candy, and their pot clubs. It keeps pot legal for AMERICANS to go there and toke up. And, it allows other drugs, like cocaine and heroin to sneak in the back door and become a problem for Dutch law enforcement. These are facts. Street crimes are on the rise in these "clubs" because of the plethora of other drugs that have managed to filter in that are NOT LEGAL. The legal system is having a hard time handling these social changes. They are slow to move because the general attitude is that Holland is a "safe place," just like Aruba. Ask anyone from the Netherlands - Aruba is where they go to really get drugs and go crazy on vacation. The fact that the VanderSloots live there and have taken their son there is only an indicator that they are looking for an even more laid back environment for themselves
Fact 7:
The VanderSloots are in heavy denial that their son has been influenced by their lax culture. Allowed to roam free in Aruba, his reputation is not that trouble free - like many spoiled American children who find themselves having to go to drug rehab due to early partying and drinking and no supervision of any type. Do you think the Europeans are not experiencing some of this same cultural phenomena that we are?
Fact 8:
The Dutch legal system is not equipped to deal with other types of serious crimes because of their "policies" and "rules." Why do you think Islamic terrorists find the Netherlands to be a safe haven? Do you think it was a coincidence that the Van Gogh filmmaker was shot down freely in the streets of Amsterdam? Their legal system is allowing a free door to all types of influences because of their "feel good" social attitudes towards others. Since these are new things to deal with, you can't believe for a minute that they are equipped or experienced at finding missing girls in their vacation spot, collecting good evidence, conducting thorough and successful investigations, or ferreting out terrorists in their streets. THey don't have the expertise or the mindset for it yet. They are just starting to get to where we were in the 1960's when the civil rights movement, the hippie movement, the anti-war movement, and the terrorist movement started in this country.
Fact 9:
Natalee Holloway is the victim here - not the VanderSloots or the Kalpoe families. The VICTIM is missing and has no one to defend herself. Her family and the rest of us here in America will see to it that she is not written off as a casualty of an inattentive culture.

As for the "crap" theories that we purport - there are so many possibilities that the Dutch government has not discussed or explored because of their secretive processes.
For instance:
1. Date rape drugs are readily available. Has there been any investigation or search for any of these in the possession of these three stupid idiot boys? These drugs make the victim appear to be totally intoxicated to others when they are being victimized by criminals.
2. What is the history of these boys? Any previous accusations by any other girls?
3. What is in their internet or text-message files?
4. Why be totally disinterested in helping to find this missing girl that they just took out in their car?
5. Why be rude to the missing girl's family if you have nothing to hide?
6. Why make up stories about what supposedly happened? Why not tell the TRUTH right away?
7. Why turn down the expertise of the FBI in actually conducting investigations? Why limit them to "observers" as though that means anything. The Dutch government is ARROGANT in believing that they can better get to the truth than the FBI. For God's sake, they don't even have a crime lab in ARUBA because they supposedly don't have any crime. (Which begs the question - do they really have no crime or do they just ignore it so they can be a good tourist draw?)

I could go on, but this is so stupid. The facts point to these three individuals and their father covering up a crime. That should not go unpunished. In the U.S., Paul VanderSloot would be held in contempt of court or charged with obstruction of justice. In the U.S., those boys would have been charged with kidnapping and murder and preparations for a trial would be underway. In the U.S., the DNA evidence would already have been collected and tested. In the U.S., those boys would have never been allowed to roam free under the guise of "good investigative work" to allow investigators to follow them around and see what they would do - oh please. That is the lamest old pink panther excuse I have heard yet. These are incompetent backwards thinking people who think their gumshoe tactics are acceptable in the age of wireless text messages and internet cafes. That's like going to Brazil and expecting a rainforest tribe to be able to solve a terrorist plot... Those of you who defend this incompetency are equally ridiculous. We are OUTRAGED in this country because we do know what kinds of tools we have to solve crimes and NONE of them are being used. It is better to do SOMETHING than to sit back and put people in jail, ignore them and hope to God they will confess. That is just stupid. He can wait it out so he can go to his college and become a lawyer just like his hack father. They should be ashamed and they should be doing something to express their sorrow to Natalee's family rather than act like poor little Joran and the Kalpoe boys are just sweet innocents. THEY TOOK THIS GIRL IN THEIR CAR AND SHE DIDN'T RETURN. WHAT MORE EVIDENCE DO YOU NEED??? They never even said "I liked her so much I am so distressed that she didn't make it back." AND WHAT KIND OF BOYS would make up a horrid story like "she was drunk so we kicked her out of the car and let her stagger back to her room." That just makes them look so respectable and upstanding. I would want to beat them just for that. AND WHAT KIND OF PARENTS RAISE THESE KINDS OF DISRESPECTFUL LITTLE PUNKS????

Parents are part of the problem here - they don't want to see what they have raised or make their minor children be accountable under the law. They are busy hiding their children's flaws under their piles of material goods rather than make them be moral and forthright people.

But of course, American culture is blamed for the Natalee Holloway murder, and anyone who expresses outrage over the baffoonish behavior of the Aruban police and prosecutors is just out of line...

Whatever. I'm not ashamed of being an American mom. I can tell you that my children will not go blindly into other countries thinking that there is a strong justice system outside of the U.S.
7 月 23 日
匿名 的图片
Dennis Campbell 发表:
We Americans believe in justice. No standard of justice says it is acceptable to rape and murder, or cover for those who do. The behavior of the van der Sloots is suspicious and suggests a strong suspicion of guilt. The Aruban authorities have demonstrated ineptitude. What would you have us do?
7 月 22 日
匿名 的图片
blondie0470 发表:
I'm proud to be a loving American mother.I blog hypotheses as we have little facts.
If you don't like it, Pull de Plug and go.
7 月 22 日
匿名 的图片
What does it matter ... 发表:
I think that YOU, as well as SCARED MONKEYS, should stop posting hypotheses about this case and stick to the facts only. I'm not American (I thank God for that), and it's tiring reading this CRAP that you all post, not only about this case, but anything else. I can't believe what I've read about this case in which plainly portrays the general American psyche; "Hire a hitman and kill these 4 bastards" ... "If I was Dave Holloway, I would get a gun and kill these three kids myself" ....

I mean .... really.
7 月 21 日

引用通告

此日志的引用通告 URL 是:
http://feirfactor.spaces.live.com/blog/cns!443F226F793809C!129.trak
引用此项的网络日志